DC METRO RESALE FEES

FAQ

Districtre.com Power Papers

DC Metro Resale Fees

What are private resale fees?
DC Metro Resale Fees may  have a number of different names: private transfer fees, reconveyance fees, recovery fees, capital recovery fees, and resale fees. They all amount to a private transfer fee paid to a developer, HOA or individual at closing each time a property is sold over a period of time. The transfer fee is attached to the property as a covenant and usually runs for a set period, often 20 or 99 years. While developers say it is a way to spread improvement costs over a longer period, opponents believe private transfer fees decrease affordability, increase potential liability, and provide no benefit to property purchasers of the community in which the property is located. As of late 2011, over 30 states have either banned or placed conditions on the practice and Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have made statements saying they won’t back mortgages containing the fees.
THE BILL
BILL H.R. 6260 In 2010, a bill was introduced in Congress (H.R. 6260) to outlaw private transfer fees at the federal level, but was not passed. FHFA Rule Eliminates Private Transfer Fees by Jann Swanson Feb 2 2011 The Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) has issued proposed rules regarding private transfer fees on properties securing mortgages intended for sale to Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, or Federal Home Loan Bank members. The rules reflect the agency’s response to 4,210 letters commenting on a “proposed guidance” outlining the issue in August 2010. The wave of comments came from interested parties that included legal and trade associations, conservation and other non-profit organizations, condominium associations, title companies, developers, and state and local government. Transfer fees are contractual arrangements where an owner pays a fixed amount or a percentage of the sales price at the time of transferring the property. The transfer fees in question are collected by third parties each time a property changes hands. The fees are memorialized in deed covenants and may benefit a homeowners’ association, conservation land bank, non-profit organization or any number of other entities. They are also used by builders and developers to provide themselves with an income stream long after a development is complete. FHFA proposed enacting restrictions on transfer fees because of concerns that they could: Increase the costs of home ownership and reduce liquidity in both primary and secondary mortgage markets; limit property transfers or render them legally uncertain; detract from the stability of the secondary mortgage market, particularly if such fees will be securitized; expose lenders, title companies, and secondary market participants to risks from unknown potential liens and title defects; contribute to reduced transparency for consumers because the fees often are not disclosed by sellers and are difficult to discover through customary title searches, especially after repeated purchases; represent dramatic, last-minute, non-financeable out-of-pocket costs for consumers; deprive subsequent homeowners of equity value; and complicate residential real-estate transactions and introduce confusion and uncertainty for home buyers. Comments received by FHFA fell generally into five categories: Advocating a complete ban on private transfer fees. Advocates said these fees increase the cost of homeownership while generating revenue for developers or investors who provide no benefits to the homeowners over time. These comments also noted that there are few binding requirements for disclosure of these fees at closing which adds to the complexity of real estate transactions. Advocating for private transfer fees for condominiums, cooperatives, and homeowners associations. Commenters maintained that private transfer fees fund the capital reserves of their communities, helping to fund improvements which increase property values, lower member fees, and that these fees are fully disclosed. Advocating for private transfer fees for tax-exempt nonprofit associations that provide direct benefits to the property and advocating for government and other entities that provide benefits to the community at large. These commenters asserted that certain non-profit organizations and agencies play important roles by supporting the creation and maintenance of community enhancements such as open space, environmental conservation, and preservation, affording housing, and transit improvements. Some comments supported fees even if they did not directly benefit the subject property. Supporting the payment of such fees to for-profit entities and also supporting the securitization and sale of transfer-fee income streams to investors. These commenters claim that transfer fees raise the same objections and confer the same benefits across the spectrum of the entities that might collect them. They also argued that transfer fees lower the cost of construction by spreading it over future buyers. Level of fees. FHFA had expressed concern about the reasonable level of fees, whether they were fixed over the life of the covenant, and if they were proportional to the benefit rendered. Comments generally urged FHFA not to consider this issue. Compliance. Commenters, primarily banks, expressed concern about their ability to compliance without excessive burdens; particularly accessing underlying documents regarding existence of such fees. Prospective Application. Concern was expressed that the final rules might be retroactive, affecting closed loans that had not yet been securitized, complicating title searches, and impacting the salability of properties with existing covenants. In response to the comments, FHFA’s proposed rule would: Exempt from the rule private transfer fees paid to homeowners associations and similar organizations and to tax-exempt non-profit organizations where the fees are used to the direct benefit of the encumbered property. FHFA will not exempt fees paid to non-profit organizations that do not provide a direct benefit to the property on the basis of traditional law that a covenant running with the land must benefit the land it burdens. Be prospective, applying only to private transfer fee covenants created after the publication date of the proposed rule. Allow an implementation period of 120 days for the regulated entities which may use reasonable means to achieve compliance with this rule. Make no attempt to consider or evaluate the level of private transfer fees.
Virginia Legislation
Legislation Prohibiting Private Developer Transfer Fees SB 931 Transfer fee covenants Some developers have attempted to secure future revenue streams by recording a 1% transfer fee, payable to the developer each time a property is sold for 99 years. This legislation prohibits such transfer fee covenants from being recorded in Virginia on or after July 1, 2011. Property Owners’ and Condo Associations may still enact these fees, as they are approved by and for the benefit of association members. Read the VA legislation text
House Finance Committee Final Rule
Tab

BUYING OR SELLING DC REAL ESTATE?

Choosing the right Realtor

Selection of the agent representing your property is crucial to success. Your agent will apply market knowledge, strategies, experience and skills towards making your DC real estate transaction the most successful possible. With nearly 25 combined years of experience in residential real estate, consistently as top producers, The Isaacs Team’s expertise and reputation are well established. Outstanding service is our hallmark so we first pose the question, “What’s important to you?” Let’s meet and talk it over.

The Isaacs Team at Evers & Company

Experience
We have the experience and expertise to help make your real estate transaction the most profitable.
Market IQ
Thanks to a large buyer base, we know DC's neighborhoods & buyer preferences
$$$
Pricing mistakes can cost you. We're great pricing strategists. Check the records.
Why work with The Isaacs Team? Our clients will tell you!
It would not be an exaggeration to say that Susan did the work of both the buyer’s and seller’s agent, spotting and solving problems using a powerful combination of intuition and experience. She brought her impressive professional network to bear on one problem to such great effect that the buyer’s lender gave me–the seller–a closing cost credit. When does that ever happen? 
Susan is sooo responsive–pretty much 24-7. She made what could have been a difficult situation very easy to navigate. I couldn’t have bought my property without her, I’m sure. I recommend Susan VERY HIGHLY. She is a delight to work with.
In today’s market in this area, you cannot rely on luck to get you that perfect place or a great deal – you need to have an agent who knows the market cold, is aggressive, and effective – Susan is all of those things and more.
When a property popped up in a neighborhood that she and I had scouted, Susan was there within the hour and insisted it was worth us leaving work to check out. If we had a less responsive Realtor, I am convinced that we would not have our amazing house now. Susan’s advice is invaluable. You need a Realtor that knows her stuff. And Susan does!
In today’s market in this area, you cannot rely on luck to get you that perfect place or a great deal – you need to have an agent who knows the market cold, is aggressive, and effective – Susan is all of those things and more.
My husband and I loved working with Susan and Alex. This was my 9th real estate purchase but the first time that I have used The Isaacs Team. They were the best agents I have worked with and I can not accurately describe how impressed we were! They were amazing and extremely detailed. They went over and above for us in neighborhood research, service, and contract negotiations. I found them to be extremely responsive, always available, and 100% competitent in their knowledge of the markets they serve. I was really impreseed by their extensive knowledge of the real estate contract. I must say that I was incredibly impressed. They made the process easy and held our hands through difficult negotiations. I will be their client for life!
We expected an extremely stressful experience when we decided to sell our home of over 25 years and buy a condo, especially because we live nearly 3000 miles away, yet the Isaacs Team was beyond exceptional in their competent guidance, attention to detail, follow through, and simply doing what they said they would do. While other realtors said, "this is what you need to do;" this team said, "we can do this for you!" Our process was smooth and quick, and they designed a strategy and negotiated a sale well above our asking price; and a purchase price below asking - both in the same market. They are also a pleasure to work with in every respect. Please know that you can turn this difficult personal event over to true professionals and emerge with happy results and fast friends. We highly recommend this team in every regard.
Susan is a true client advocate who worked tirelessly on my behalf to ensure my purchasing goals were met. We hit some seller stumbling blocks along the way, and Susan used her experience and knowledge to ensure every box was checked on my behalf – She was my personal Bulldog. Her experience in the builder realm proved extremely valuable during the entire process.
Susan and Alex are superstar agents. There is no one else I’d want on my side of a real estate transaction. My wife and I first met Susan in 2010 when she helped us buy our first home, a condo. We were so impressed by her deep local knowledge, tenacious negotiating, 24/7 efforts on our behalf, and clear guidance on the home-buying process that we didn’t consider going with anyone else when we decided to buy a 3-BR in our dream neighborhood. We were not disappointed. After a few weeks, we found the perfect house at the perfect listing price. We knew it would be competitive, but Susan and Alex provided expert advice on how to make the offer, and in the end, we provided terms just attractive enough to end the process in our favor, but no higher than final appraisal and just above what their agent later admitted was their line. They also did a fabulous job of staging and selling our condo, which netted $30K over selling price after six strong offers during just two-days of being on the market. They get amazing results and are a blast to work with. 
Susan was an invaluable part of my new home purchase from beginning to end. She quickly understood what I liked, previewed properties and showed me homes that fit our criteria. She made herself extremely available through the process and worked with us through every aspect of the transaction. Susan was so much fun as an agent that she took the anxiety out of the home buying process. I would work with Susan again in a heartbeat.
Susan and Alex are superstar agents. There is no one else I’d want on my side of a real estate transaction. My wife and I first met Susan in 2010 when she helped us buy our first home, a condo. We were so impressed by her deep local knowledge, tenacious negotiating, 24/7 efforts on our behalf, and clear guidance on the home-buying process that we didn’t consider going with anyone else when we decided to buy a 3-BR in our dream neighborhood. We were not disappointed. After a few weeks, we found the perfect house at the perfect listing price. We knew it would be competitive, but Susan and Alex provided expert advice on how to make the offer, and in the end, we provided terms just attractive enough to end the process in our favor, but no higher than final appraisal and just above what their agent later admitted was their line. They also did a fabulous job of staging and selling our condo, which netted $30K over selling price after six strong offers during just two-days of being on the market. They get amazing results and are a blast to work with.
Susan responded immediately and impressed me with her patience and almost supernatural ability to find the perfect place for me despite some significant constraints (time, location, finances). I was not an easy case, but she never made me feel like I was a ‘burden’ or ‘not her first priority’. Above all, she treated me with respect and honesty.
Susan is knowledgeable, friendly and very responsive–she got back to us immediately to answer any of our questions at any hour. Even as first-time homebuyers who could be somewhat indecisive at times, she understood what we were looking for in a home, didn’t hesitate to answer our questions and always had our best interests in mind. Her warm, welcoming attitude and confident guidance really took the stress out of a process that, before we met Susan, we had assumed would be overwhelming and beyond our reach.
Susan not only worked hard to help my wife and me find the perfect place, she was a dogged (and effective) negotiator on our behalf once we zeroed-in. She knows the market and knows the area, but best of all she knows how to play hardball and get things done—exactly what we needed in an agent.
Susan not only worked hard to help my wife and me find the perfect place, she was a dogged (and effective) negotiator on our behalf once we zeroed-in. She knows the market and knows the area, but best of all she knows how to play hardball and get things done—exactly what we needed in an agent.

CONNECT

Selling DC real estate? Let us show you how we can help.

Join The Discussion

Get in Touch